Lyanna's dishonor - baby Jon Snow's secret originsīrandon's dishonor - the secret that Brandon dishonored Catelyn while they were betrothed Poor Ned leaves Starkfall with secrets and lies: Ned realized what a dick Brandon was, dishonoring Catelyn by sleeping with Ned's crush from the Tourney With all this grief, Ashara kills herself over losing her brother and her lover to misunderstandings, and losing her daughter probably to natural causes. The stillborn daughter she recently had was also Brandon's bastard daughter. Ned also tells Ashara that Lyanna was never kidnapped by Rhaegar, and Brandon was executed over this lie.Īshara then reveals that she and Brandon slept together while Brandon was in King's Landing after they met at the Tourney of Harrenhal a year earlier. Ned and Arthur didn't need to fight because their interest in protecting Jon and Lyanna were the same.but this was after the fact. He hopes to see his crush from the Tourney at Harrenhal, Ashara DayneĪt Starkfall (where everything goes wrong):Īshara learns from Ned, that he just killed Arthur Dayne, her brother. He needed to go to a seaport and find a ship Ned goes to Starfall because coincidentally:
R+L=J theory is essentially the story of Lyanna Stark abandoning her honor to Robert Baratheon's betrothal for Rhaegar Targaryen.for love.ī+A=stillborn is essentially the story of Brandon Stark dishonoring Catelyn Tully's betrothal for Ashara Dayne.either for love, or for a one night stand, or two.Īt the Tower of Joy, Ned learns from Lyanna that she and Rhaegar were in love, and Rickard & Brandon Stark died over a lie.Īfter Lyanna dies, Ned needed a ship to travel back to Winterfell while hiding the existence of Jon Snow. Though it has been discussed multiple times, here is the refresher: Well it would involve the two theories of R+L=J, and Brandon + Ashara = Stillborn. What if GRRM's initial hidden intention was " Starkfall"? The location and story of how the honorable House Stark was not really that honorable.Īnd what if anything in regards to a falling stone from outer space and the legend of Dayne family was written as a secondary by GRRM? What if the name "Starfall" on the map was not originally meant for the shooting star? Starfall is the seat of House Dayne, the site of a fallen shooting star, whose stone forged the famous sword Dawn.
0 kommentar(er)
